Opinion  July 22, 2021  Mary M. Lane

Reframed: John Sloan's “Sunday, Women Drying Their Hair”

Courtesy of Addison Gallery of American Art. Museum purchase, 1938.67.

John Sloan, Sunday, Women Drying Their Hair, 1912. Oil on canvas. 26 1/8 in. x 32 1/8 in. (66.36 cm x 81.6 cm). Addison Gallery of American Art, Phillips Academy, Andover, MA.

The July 2021 Focus for Reframed is American Heat

In the original 1957 lyrics to the song “America” from the Broadway musical West Side Story, Puerto Rican immigrants dance across a rooftop in the stifling heat of smog-filled Manhattan. “Immigrant goes to America, many ‘hellos’ in America, nobody knows in America,” the women sing.

The immigrant women in Sunday, Women Drying Their Hair, a painting owned by the Addison Gallery of American Art and painted in 1912 by John Sloan (1871-1951), were European immigrants who worked in factories four decades before the immigrants in West Side Story.

Still, the Broadway lyrics also apply to Drying. In both rooftop scenes, set in the summertime, young female immigrants strive to achieve the American dream while maintaining dignity.

Sloan began his artistic career copying the works of great masters, including the animal portraits by Albrecht Dürer, but he later began capturing scenes of immigrant life.

The artist was a founder of the Ashcan School, an artistic group that depicted urban centers set apart from the extreme elite classes that paid other artists exorbitant sums to paint their sprawling mansions.

Sloan’s studio in Manhattan’s lower east side overlooked Cornelia Street, and from his window he could see the “the human comedies which were regularly staged for my enjoyment by the humble roof-top players of Cornelia Street,” Sloan noted at the time.

Cornelia Street is best known today by many readers as the subject of a Taylor Swift song about her 5,500 sq. ft. rental on the street for which she paid roughly $40,000 monthly.

Courtesy of Addison Gallery of American Art. Museum purchase, 1938.67.

John Sloan, detail of Sunday, Women Drying Their Hair, 1912. Oil on canvas. 26 1/8 in. x 32 1/8 in. (66.36 cm x 81.6 cm). Addison Gallery of American Art, Phillips Academy, Andover, MA.

Yet a century ago, Swift’s rooftop was one of the sweatshops that Sloan could see from his studio. An avid advocate of workers' rights, Sloan supported policies that seemed radical then, yet are taken for granted today, including a ban on child labor.

For many immigrants in the early twentieth century, these rooftops were “an oasis from their very cramped and very unsanitary living conditions,” shares the Addison’s curator Gordon Dearborn Wilkins in an interview with Art & Object.

“Yet this oasis,” notes Wilkins, was one that was hardly private, a point of which Sloan was well aware. “You could think of the rooftop as an extension of your personal space, but you were also on display,” said Wilkins.

Sloan was careful neither to denigrate nor to deify the immigrants whom he painted, including the women in Drying. Still, his work leaves room for much interpretation, as a great work of art should.

However, it is clear that these women are intent upon seizing the opportunities, however mercurial, that Manhattan afforded them, with ambition and dignity.

About the Author

Mary M. Lane

Mary M. Lane is an art market journalist, an art historian, and the author of Hitler's Last Hostages: Looted Art and the Soul of the Third Reich. Reach her on Twitter: MaryLaneWSJ and Instagram: MaryLaneAuthor

Subscribe to our free e-letter!

Webform

Latest News

MoMA’s “Matisse: The Red Studio” Unveils Artist-Patron Conflict
An interior view of Matisse’s atelier in the Parisian suburb of Issy-les-…
Pre-Columbian Latin America: The Chavín of Ancient Peru
The Chavín are perhaps best known for their peculiar artistic style and…
Feminism & Violence Coexist in Artemisia Gentileschi's Judith
Gentileschi’s Judith stands out because it shows the act of a woman forcefully…
“Quiet as It’s Kept”: Whitney Biennial Returns with Middling Show
Silenced by the pandemic last year, The Whitney Biennial returns with an…
“William Klein: YES” at the International Center of Photography
The International Center of Photography (ICP) will present a major…