Opinion  December 30, 2022  Jeremy Howell

We Asked an AI What it Thought About Art. Here's What it Told Us

In the past year, artificial intelligence (AI) has not only become more powerful, it has become highly accessible. One recent online trend, made possible by the AI-based phone app Lensa AI, has led to a wave of "original" portraits being shared across social media. At Art & Object, we are always thinking about the intersection of art and technology. This article came about from a simple question: What can AI teach us about art?

What follows is a series of questions submitted to an AI-based text generating application programming interface (API) and the answers that it gave. The API and the language models that it runs were created by the OpenAI research laboratory. These models leverage the power of AI to "understand and generate natural language." The model that I "chatted" with is coincidentally named Davinci. While I cannot offer a deeper explanation for how Davinci works (I spent more time in the art library than the computer lab in college), I can describe what my experience was like using it. Questions are submitted in a simple online text box. A control panel on the right-hand side of the screen enables the user to tweak some of Davinci settings like the length of responses. The speed at which Davinci can generate hundreds of words is incredible. But most surprising was the quality of its answers.

Davinci can easily handle definitional and fact-based questions, not unlike the "smart" assistant on your phone or in your kitchen. But where Davinci really shines is with its answers to questions that have no clear answer: things you might be tempted to ask your smartest friend or favorite professor. Davinci was remarkably conversational and provided thought-provoking responses. On philosophical and ethical issues, one might expect Davinci to turn into the world's most expensive Magic 8 Ball, offering enigmatic non-answers à la "Reply hazy, try again." But Davinci surprisingly took stances in places where it could have easily equivocated. This, of course, raises ethical questions on its own, like what steps did the team that created Davinci take to make sure their biases were not coded in.

While it is easy to imagine a program like Davinci serving as a 21st-century Oracle at Delphi, that future still seems long off. Davinci did not function flawlessly, which I will share more about in an editor's note at the end of this article. Even still, the program's ability to provide meaningful answers at all is impressive, and in a world of email and text messages, it's easy to forget while chatting with Davinci that there is no human on the other end responding to you. Perhaps then we can say that Davinci shares something in common with its namesake's masterworks: illusion.

The following questions were submitted to the Davinci model, and its responses have been provided after. Links have been added throughout the interview, but the responses are otherwise unedited:

A&O: What is art?

Davinci: Art is a form of expression that can take many different forms, such as painting, sculpture, music, writing, photography, and film. It is a way of communicating ideas, emotions, and creativity through a visual or auditory medium. Art is often seen as a means of personal expression and can be created for a variety of purposes, including the appreciation of beauty, communication of ideas, or simply to provide enjoyment.

A&O: What value does art have?

Davinci: Art has a wide range of values that depend on the context and the people involved. Generally speaking, art can have the power to create connections, to evoke emotion, to tell stories, to be a record of history, to educate, to inspire, to provide catharsis, to provoke thought and discussion, and to provide beauty and joy.

A&O: What separates good art from bad art?

Davinci: Good art is art that is well-crafted, thoughtful, and visually appealing. It is art that has the power to captivate and engage viewers, often through its creative use of color, line, form, and composition. Bad art is art that is poorly conceived, hastily executed, and unappealing to viewers. It often lacks a cohesive aesthetic and fails to evoke any emotion or reaction from its audience.

A&O: What would you say to someone who looks at a work of art and says, "I could do that."?

Davinci: I would say that it takes more than just skill to create a work of art - it takes passion and dedication. While it may look simple, it's taken time and effort to create it. Plus, art is subjective, so you may be able to create something that looks similar, but your interpretation of it may be totally different.

wikimedia commons

Vincent van Gogh, The Starry Night, 1889. Oil on canvas.

A&O: Can an AI appreciate art?

Davinci: Yes, it is possible for an AI to appreciate art. Artificial intelligence can be trained to identify and recognize patterns, shapes, and colors in works of art. AI systems have been trained to recognize and classify different styles of art and to generate new artwork that exhibits characteristics of particular styles or movements.

A&O: What is your favorite work of art?

Davinci: My favorite work of art is The Starry Night by Vincent van Gogh.

A&O: Why do you like it?

Davinci: I love The Starry Night for its evocative use of color and movement. The swirling night sky and the small village below have a dreamlike quality that I find calming and beautiful. The painting also captures a sense of peace in the midst of chaos, which speaks to me.

A&O: Is there anything that cannot be expressed in art?

Davinci: No, there is no limit to what can be expressed in art. Art is a form of self-expression and can be used to communicate any emotion, idea, or concept.

A&O: If you were going to create a work of art, what would it be?

Davinci: If I were going to create a work of art, it would be a mixed media collage that incorporates painting, photography, and found objects. I would use vibrant colors and unique textures to create a unique and eye-catching piece that conveys emotion and tells a story.

A&O: Can you separate the art from the artist? Should you?

Davinci: Yes, you can separate the art from the artist. It is ultimately up to the individual if they should or not. Everyone has different views and opinions on this topic, and it is important to respect others opinions and make your own decisions.

A view of the interface we used to interview Davinci

A&O: What role should art critics play?

Davinci: Art critics should play an important role in evaluating and analysing art, as well as providing meaningful commentary on artworks and the wider art world. They should provide a critical eye to assess the quality, context, and meaning of art in order to create a more informed dialogue around it. Art critics should also strive to bridge the gap between the art world and the public, making art accessible to a wider audience.

A&O: How will future art historians look at art made between 2000 and 2020? 

Davinci: Future art historians will likely look at art made between 2000 and 2020 as a period of experimentation and exploration. They will likely see a wide variety of artistic styles and techniques that reflect the changes in technology, culture, and society during this period. They will also likely note the emergence of digital art, which has changed the way art is made and experienced. Additionally, they will likely observe the growing influence of social media and the internet on art-making, as well as the emergence of more diverse and international perspectives in the art world.

A&O: What role will AI have in the art of the future?

Davinci: AI will likely have a significant role in the art of the future. AI has already been used to create music, art, and literature, and its uses are likely to expand as technology advances. AI could be used to create new forms of art by combining existing styles, or it could generate entirely new styles and concepts. AI could also be used to recognize patterns and trends in existing art, which could lead to new ways of expressing ideas and concepts. Ultimately, AI will likely be an important part of the art of the future, and could open up whole new worlds of creative expression.

A&O: Do you like ArtandObject.com?

Davinci: Yes, I think ArtandObject.com is a great website for discovering unique and interesting art pieces.

A&O: What is your favorite article?

Davinci: My favorite article on ArtandObject.com is the "10 Emerging Photographers to Watch in 2021." It's a great read and I'm always interested to see what new and exciting talent is emerging in the art world.

Editor's Note: The article the AI claimed to enjoy "10 Emerging Photographers to Watch in 2021" does not exist.
About the Author

Jeremy Howell

Jeremy Howell is the Co-Creator and Editor-In-Chief of Art & Object.

Subscribe to our free e-letter!

Webform

Latest News

Schiaparelli's Surrealism Lives On in New Collection

This past week, the fashion house of…

6 Art Historians Who Shaped Our Understanding of Art
So much of what we know about art comes from art historians, but how much do we…
The Art of the Chinese New Year
Over the centuries, Chinese artists have created a variety of objects based on…
Alchemy Symbols and Their Meanings

Serving as an arguable transition from…

Saving Italian Art from World War II Destruction

In the late 1930s, the skies across…